Originally Posted by
CitizenBBN
I think I sold my last one but I may pick one up: Winchester 1897. Series E (has a tube ejector versus having to cycle the rounds to unload).
Why? I'ts dog reliable as a pump, and it can be slam fired. You pump it the first time and after that if you hold down the trigger every time it pumps it fires. I'd cut down the barrel to minimum length for the law and the tube.
I also sold off a Saiga 12 Ga AK-47. I may get one again, they aren't stupid expensive. They also have a knock off in 410 that I like as long as I can get a 10 round mag for it. 410 self defense loads are the bomb. not as massive as the 12 ga with 00 buck, but very controllable and plenty enough to do the job.
If I was staying traditional I'm thinking pump, and you can't go wrong with the 500 or the 870. Both very reliable and lots of customization options. 500 is a bit easier to break down IMO.
Frankly I'd go with a 20ga for home defense if it was a 500 or 870. Plenty of power with defense loads and a little less over penetration and more control.
Also consider if you shoot a gun inside your house at night you'll be blind and deaf immediately. Personally I'd rather be deafened by a 410 than a 12 ga in a closed space.
Honestly for all that it's why I like the Taurus Judge and S&W Governor. 5 rounds so you're about even with a shotgun, and the 410 with defense loads can do a lot, and you have all the freedom of movement of a pistol.